It really hit me over the last week like a ton of bricks.
Parochialism within the Ohio GOP ranks is alive and well.
The cowardice of attacks via anonymity is flourishing.
The venom we have for others within our own party is
palpable.
Conclusion: We are
not even close to being tired of losing elections in the General Election vs
dems.
In fact, judging by some recent actions we would like to
make losing a habit for many years to come (get used to hearing the term
“generational minority”…if we are not careful it is going to be part of the
Ohio GOP vernacular).
The Voinovich seat is open and potentially in peril and
other than that the GOP firmly controls the Ohio Senate, the Ohio Supreme Court
and the Auditor’s seat…that is pretty much it.
We have lost EVERYTHING else.
You would think we would be tired of losing by now and ready
to work towards the one, unifying, common goal of defeating dems at the ballot
box, but we are nowhere near being in that mindset.
Obviously, we need to lose more elections, become more
firmly entrenched in the minority and shoot ourselves in the foot as a party
more than we have already done before we will be ready to work together.
I will go one-by-one so there is no mistaking what I am talking
about:
The House Minority
Caucus:


The Batchelder crew (i.e. members, staff, vendors &
consultants) still hates the Dolan crew (Exhibit A is the all-male,
all-pro-Batch minority leadership team) and the Dolan crew still hates the
Batch crew (Exhibit B is the photo below which I believe is of Bill Coley). My best advice to each individual on the
Dolan crew is this: No one likes a sore
loser. Give up the ghost. You lost (maybe not entirely in a fair
manner, but you lost nonetheless). Move
on. A number of you will have
opportunities in the future if you get rid of your Keystone Light “bitter beer
face”:

Continue to be bitter and wonder “what could have been” then
some (or all) of these opportunities might fade away.
Many of you feel as if Batch and his crew had more to do
with the House Republican Caucus being in the minority than anything Budish,
SEIU and the dems did combined by doing nothing to help Dolan (and oftentimes
working against him actively either in the light of day or behind the scenes).
There is a perception (true or false) that the Dolan crew
was focused on (a) keeping the majority and then once that majority was secured
to then be in a position to (b) have Dolan lead the razor thin majority as
Speaker while the Batchelder crew was focused on (a) making sure Batchelder was
in charge no matter what the head count ended up being when the dust settled be
it 52 seats, 50 seats, 48 seats or lower and (b) hope that what he had a
majority of votes within was a caucus in the majority and not a caucus in the
minority. These were two very different
efforts with two very different goals and neither guy ended up getting what he
wanted.
Even now, many within the caucus and lobbying community
believe that a united GOP caucus would have been able to keep the majority, but
a completely bifurcated GOP caucus created an opening for the dems and a
climate for something like losing five seats by a combined total of 1,200 votes
to occur.
For the Batch crew:
You won leadership of the minority caucus, but that is relatively
equivalent to winning an air conditioner in the Arctic…yep it was nice to win
something, but it really isn’t worth all that much to you. The only way your victory (with a small “v”) ends
up meaning anything is if you win the majority in 2010 and Batchelder becomes
Speaker.
I have the following questions for the House Minority
Caucus:
1. Are you united in
this budget process or do you have some independent souls who are going to do
their own thing?
2. Are you raising
money as a united minority in large sums (strong commitments now to be
collected later in 2009) or not?
3. Are you
aggressively recruiting good candidates for all 99 House seats right now (you
should be actively into candidate recruitment for the better part of 60 days
already in 09)?
4. If you close your
eyes and are asked to picture your enemy does a picture of Strickland, Redfern,
Budish or a fellow member of your own caucus pop into your head?
5. Are you doing your
part to insure Republicans are in the best position possible to control the
Apportionment Board after the 2010 elections?
Unfortunately, the answers to too many of these questions
are not the right ones for regaining a majority.
The internal fighting and backstabbing that is proliferating
is a sure way to 40 seats not a viable strategy to get to 50.
Dolan and his crew hate the current situation of things and
Batch and his crew do not like it that much either, but the reality of the
current situation is that wishing things were different is not going to get you
anywhere. The time for wishing things
were different is over. The time for
doing is here.
The Race to take
on Ted Strickland
The anonymous attack on Kasich last week was enough to send
me to the fucking moon. Having given a
pound of my own flesh back in 2004 to an anonymous attack you can imagine how
much I loathe people who hide behind anonymity, slander and innuendo.

I do not know with absolute 100% certainty who was behind
last week’s anonymous attack on Kasich, but after comparing notes with two
other people I am 90% sure I know who did it.
So I will tell him (the perpetrator was a guy) now that he is on
notice. If he does something like that
again then I will “out” him on this blog and I will provide my “case” to the
readers of this blog and they can decide for themselves after reviewing my
evidence if I am right or wrong. Don’t
think I’m serious? Try me.
If I don’t serve any purpose with this blog other than
outing Republicans who are pussies who anonymously attack other Republicans then
I am fine with that. I think we can do
more than that with this blog, but if we do nothing else other than reduce the
number of anonymous “Republican on Republican” guerrilla attacks then we have
provided a worthwhile public service in my opinion.
Governor Strickland is trying to position this state for the
largest tax increase (by far) in Ohio’s history. He must be stopped from passing his proposed
budget (in the short run) and he must be removed from office for our kids &
grandkids sake on November 4, 2010 (for the long run).
The only way that is going to happen is if (1) Kasich
announces, forms a committee at the SOS office and starts raising money in
droves ASAP and (2) everyone coalesces behind Kasich and quits these bullshit
ankle biting, knock fellow GOPers off at the knees tactics. Focus attacks on Strickland not on Kasich.
The other two
Apportionment Board seats and the two non-Apportionment Board seats

Mary Taylor needs to cease & desist all talk of
potentially running against Portman and focus all of her time and energy into
raising funds & talking to voters about running for Auditor again. Jill Miller Zimon whom I like, respect and
envy her writing ability (don’t read that the wrong way…I am not saying I agree
with her…she and I do not agree on much, but her command of the English
language is far superior to mine) asked me about Mary Taylor and Jennifer
Lee.
Jill thinks both of them should run for Senate. I respectfully disagree. The comparison is an "apples & oranges
comparison." They are both female,
down-ticket statewide officeholders, but the similarities end there. Jennifer Lee has worked tirelessly while in
office to build a legitimate statewide organization. Mary has not.
SOS has been a 24/7 gig for Jennifer Lee and from all accounts I have
been given…well, I will be kind and say that Mary has not put in those kinds of
hours as Auditor (Mary is in 1000% better shape than Jennifer Lee. That does not happen by accident. Get my drift?
That is just one example of “different uses of time during the workday”
when comparing these two). Jennifer Lee
can rely on the aid of EMILY’S LIST and Mary has no GOP counterpart to that
organization to turn to. There is a
decent sized coalition of people who are pro-JLB or anti-Lee Fisher and Mary
does not have that kind of dynamic working in her favor on the GOP side. 95% of people within the party feel like she
is pissing in Portman’s pool and it is time for her to get out. There are other things I could point out here
as “differentiators”, but doing so would just put a big target on my back. Suffice it to say that Mary would not have
the resources to compete with Portman.
He would buy the primary. It is
just that simple.
The other Apportionment Board seat is the seat I probably
hear the most about and it is the seat which will probably have the largest
impact on the next ten years of politics in Ohio. And, from what I am seeing from the bleacher
seats, it looks to me like Republicans are going to shoot themselves in the
foot here and do the dems dirty work for them.
Mark my word: If
things do not change and change quickly then the Republicans will lose this
seat instead of the dems actually winning this seat. Make no mistake about it. There is a very clear distinction between
those two things happening.
Right now Republicans are doing everything they can to lose
this race.




From what I am hearing Jon Husted, Sandy O’Brien, Rob
Montgomery and Kevin Coughlin are all interested in running for this seat.
Any primary whatsoever in this seat will mean bad news for
the candidate who survives the primary and limps into the general election.
Jon Husted was not a great Speaker of the House. I think he did a decent/good job, but I don’t
think he did a great job. The thing you
have to keep in mind though is that it is a nearly impossible job to be great
at. Don’t believe me? Ask Jo Ann Davidson or Larry
Householder. It really is an awful,
thankless job which by design makes you piss people off on a pretty regular
basis, there are never enough hours in the day to get everything done that
needs to get done while you are Speaker and by the time your term is done you and
your Chief of Staff end up having a lot of people mad at you, not very many
people happy with you and you end up severely disliking most of the members you
carried on your back and coddled for nearly your entire term as Speaker while
trying to retain the majority.
I wish Jon Husted had done a number of things different, but
it is what it is and the facts of our current situation is that there is NO
OTHER CANDIDATE who has the relationships statewide within the party and within
the donor community who can raise the $5-6 million which will be needed to win
the Secretary of State election next year.
There is no one else who can do it THAT IS INTERESTED other
than Husted.
I just do not see a scenario where we can talk Betty
Montgomery, Jim Petro or Mike DeWine into running for Secretary of State. And, frankly, most of the people who have a
problem with Jon Husted not being conservative enough for this seat would have
as much, if not more, of a problem with Montgomery, Petro or DeWine as they
would with Husted anyway.
Husted is the best candidate available. Period.
This is what some people within the GOP ranks just do not get. The synapses do not connect. There is no magical pot of money for the
likes of Sandy O’Brien, Rob Montgomery or Kevin Coughlin. There just isn’t. Husted can raise the necessary funds to beat
Jen Brunner, Bill Mason, Paula Brooks or any of the other folks I have heard
mentioned for this seat.
We tried the “Sandy O’Brien experiment” in 2006 and it
failed miserably. Yes, she is a
woman. Yes, she is a conservative. Yes, she has a great last name. Yes, she is a proven vote-getter in a county
of 120,000 people (woo woo). Yes, her
son is pretty smart and one of the other statewide campaigns would be lucky to
have him at the helm. But all of that
stuff was true in 2006 also. The brass
tax of the situation is that she is a decent candidate in a primary, but she is
not that great of a candidate in a general election. She has not been able to raise money in the
past and that trend would continue in 2009 & 2010 if she were to run for
this race.
Rob Montgomery is in a phenomenal position to take David
Goodman’s place as State Senator and I think that is exactly what he should
do. He could be a significant player
within the caucus in his first two years and if he plays his cards right he
could be in a position in the future that could be very good for himself and
for Central Ohio. And, quite frankly, I
think he would actually like being a State Senator. He is still a young guy who has a lot of good
years ahead of him. He would be much
wiser to go the State Senate route in 2010 (work his ass off in 09-10 to take
Goodman’s seat then continue working his ass off in 11 & 12 then take a
look at the political landscape in 13 to evaluate a potential bid for a
down-ticket statewide office in 2014 OR stick it out in the Senate and try to
advance within the ranks there). That is
the route Rob should take. If Rob or Ron
reads this blog I hope they will take this advice. Just because it is free advice in a blog does
not mean it is bad advice J
So far Kevin Coughlin’s efforts at running statewide have
been equivalent to a monkey trying to f@#k a football. Now all of you KC lovers don’t start writing
me hate mail. I like Kevin. I respect Kevin. I think Kevin has a lot going for him, but I
am just scratching my head as to his actions up to this point in time. First he had the announcement that wasn’t the
announcement in the ABJ. Then he had the
“official announcement” that he did over the internet. Frankly, I liked the medium he chose and I
actually personally liked his message in his announcement & that he looked
at the camera squarely & confidently (unfortunately I am in the minority on
that front and a lot of people I have talked to thought his announcement in a
dimly lit office reminded them of a grainy Al Qaeda video). What I have issue with is the fact that he
actually did the announcement at all.
Now he is the announced candidate for Gov. Many within the GOP ranks perceive this act
as an act of aggression towards John Kasich because many within the GOP ranks
believe Kasich is going to be our candidate thus Coughlin’s announcement is not
perceived as an announcement against Ted Strickland. It is perceived as an announcement and act of
aggression against John Kasich. Not
good, Kevin. Not good.
I think Coughlin would have been better served by
campaigning around the state telling people that he definitely would be running for Governor if John Kasich would
not be stepping up to the plate to take on Ted Strickland (unfortunately still
a very realistic scenario), but would defer to Kasich if he got into the race
and at that point would either run for a down-ticket statewide office if that
opportunity presented itself or, worst case scenario, this effort was just a
head-start on a statewide run in 2014. I
think that message would have been very well received and Kevin would be in a
much better position than what he currently finds himself in. Now he is the announced candidate and until
Kasich gets into the race he has no excuse whatsoever to get out of the race. Kasich is scared of filing with a small
figure for the mid-year campaign finance reporting period (cut-off June 30th
& the figures go public July 31st) so do not look for a Kasich
announcement for Governor any sooner than July 1st if it even
happens at all. So Kevin needs to keep
posturing as if he is running for Gov for all of March, April, May and, at a
minimum, June. My guess is Kasich won’t
want his announcement to get lost amid 4th of July festivities so he
is probably really looking at a mid-July announcement. Coughlin looks weak if he gets out of the race
immediately so he at least has to “do some soul searching, talk to his family,
talk to his supporters, etc” prior to announcing that he is getting out of the
race and backing Kasich so realistically Coughlin has to stay in this Gov race
at least until August. My guess is he
probably thinks he can “fall back into” a down-ticket statewide race (or
negotiate for one of them) at that point in time, but I think that is just
wishful thinking. Both grassroots and
financial commitments will be too far down the paths of other candidates by
then and there is no one to negotiate with for a seat. Bennett is gone and DeWine doesn’t have the
stick yet within the GOP ranks to work out a deal. He is no 20 year Chairman. He does not have that kind of power. He is a 45 day Chairman. We are living in the wild, wild west right
now and there isn’t anyone alive who can broker that kind of deal. That said, if he tries to get into a primary
at that point in time all he ends up looking like and being is an asshole.
But, alas, all is not negative in Coughlin world. If Kasich and Mike DeWine both take a pass at
Gov then Kevin ends up looking like the smartest guy on the planet because he
will be running for the exact seat the party needs him to be running for: Governor.
He will have just figured it out months ahead of us. If that ends up being the situation we find
ourselves in then I will offer my apologies for doubting his Nostradamus-like
abilities.
I believe the more likely scenario is that Kasich announces
in July and then Coughlin will EITHER have to stay in the race, run a primary
against Kasich, do better than anyone expected, but still lose & bloody
Kasich up enough in the process that Strickland wins re-election easily,
Coughlin shoulders much of the blame for such an outcome and his political
career is over…
OR…
Kasich announces in July and then after doing some
soul-searching, talking with his family & supporters he comes to the
conclusion sometime in August or September that he is dropping out of the Gov’s
race, deferring to Kasich and campaigning statewide full-time to help Kasich
get elected Governor. If Kasich wins
then hopefully he is an honorable guy (like Ted was with Fingerhut) and he
gives Kevin something meaningful in his Administration while letting him
basically spend four years running around the state campaigning for a
down-ticket statewide run in 14. If
Kasich loses then Coughlin will be in the position that he campaigned for all
of 09 & 10, was a huge team player for Kasich & the party and I believe
that people will be grateful for that and remember that as he puts his efforts
together for a statewide run in 2014. I
hope for the party’s sake and for Kevin’s sake personally that he does this
last paragraph’s scenario if the situation presents itself.
I lay all of that out with Jon, Sandy, Rob & Kevin
because I truly believe with every fiber of my being that the only way the GOP
wins the Secretary of State race is if both of these things happen:
1)
Jon
Husted is our candidate
2)
Jon Husted does not have a credible Republican
primary
If anyone other than Husted is our candidate then the
dollars will NOT be raised and our candidate will not win. Sandy cannot do it (she has proven
that). Rob cannot do it. Kevin cannot do it. If any of these three people (or any combo of
the three) run against Husted in the primary they will not win. You may think they will win or have some
legitimate chance of winning, but you are just smoking crack. You are just plain wrong. Sorry.
Sorry to speak so plainly & directly, but the time for plain talk
has arrived. Please do not be a part of
weakening Husted for the general election.
That is ALL you would be doing if you ran against him in the primary.
If Husted needs to spend $1,000,000 to beat any of these people
in a primary he will spend it. If he
needs to spend $2,000,000 to beat any of these people in a primary then he will
spend that. Are you starting to get the
picture? He will raise and spend
whatever he needs to so he is victorious in the primary.
Here is where I REALLY need my conservative friends who
might think about supporting one of these candidates against Husted to pay
attention. Please focus. Are you ready? Ok.
Here I go. I have three points I
need to get across to you:
1)
Money follows power therefore GOP $ is very
limited. We used to have power
as a party so fundraising was a lot easier.
We were used to operating in a world from 1994-2006 where it seemed like
the money came from a never-empty, always-flowing money faucet. That world no longer exists. Money follows power and other than the oasis
known as the Ohio Senate we do not have it.
The real power structures within this state are now controlled by the
dems so the amount of money both BY RACE & IN TOTAL is now very limited for
GOP candidates compared to the 94-06 era.
2)
A wounded-from-an-ugly-primary Jon Husted is
a probable loser in the General Election in this Apportionment Board Seat. Husted will spend whatever he has to spend be
it a million, two million, more…whatever…so why in the world would you want him
to have to take a portion of those, as explained, limited amount of dollars and
spend them in a primary? If he spends
$1.2 million (my guess-timate/ballpark figure for a primary win) in a primary
then that will definitely impact his ability to get to $5-6 million in the
general election. Further, he will be a
weaker general election candidate because he will have had to gone out to the
right in the primary to be successful.
Coming back closer to the middle in the general just means that this SOS
race will end up being more expensive if he is to be victorious.
3)
My most important point of all for you: These statewide races do not happen in a
vacuum. They just do not. What goes on in this SOS race will have a big
impact on someone all of you conservatives love. An expensive primary for Husted will greatly
affect Husted’s chances of being successful in the general and it will most
definitely impact Mandel’s fundraising and his ability to put himself in the
best position to defeat Boyce. Re-read
points 1) & 2) above, really think about this point #3 and you will realize
I am correct.
Conservatives in this state are great with
grassroots and getting out the vote, but are not nearly as good on the money
side of things. The major funding
sources for Republican politics in this state will most assuredly put their
dollars in the three Apportionment Board seats FIRST and then if they have
anything leftover THEN they will think about funding the Treasurer race and the
AG race. If the SOS race gets really
expensive because Husted has to fight off a credible primary opponent then I am
100% positive that Mandel’s fundraising will get hurt.
So taking a shot at Husted and coming up
short will hurt both Husted and Mandel.

I implore you to not hurt either of
them. A Husted primary weakens
Mandel. I will say that again in case you missed it the first time:
A Husted primary weakens Mandel.
The AG Race is not
a throwaway race. This race also
will have an impact on the GOP ticket.

Right now Mike DeWine is trying to figure out whether he is
running for anything at all, AG or Chief Justice. I hope he opts against not running or running
for Chief. I hope he runs for AG. If he runs for AG he will either win and be
positioned very well for a rematch against Sherrod in 12 or for something else
in 14. If he loses he will have “taken
one for the team/been a real team player” by taking on the dem’s golden
boy/gubernatorial candidate in waiting.
Even if he loses he will have created a groundswell of support within
the GOP and, more importantly, will have put Cordray in a position where he had
to spend every last penny to win the race.

I like Dave Yost a lot and I do not know Mike Crites, but I
hear a lot of great things about him, too.
The fact of the matter is that if DeWine runs then Cordray will not have
any money left to help out whoever runs against Taylor, Husted or Mandel and if
Yost or Crites is the opponent then Cordray will have SEVEN FIGURES to pump
into whichever races need extra funding to prevail.

The mathematics of the AG race are just very simple. DeWine is good for the rest of the ticket in
this Apportionment Board year and Yost & Crites are not. Now if DeWine will not run for AG then we
could do way worse than either Dave Yost or Mike Crites. Personally, I am biased towards Yost.
Now some conservatives have said they would rather have
Cordray than DeWine. To that I will just
point out three things (none of which will be the doling out of special counsel
& collections work which are the things you probably only know about):
1)
Where in the heck do you think most of the
judges in this state come from? This may
come as a shock to you, but judges do not grow on trees. Sorry.
The tooth fairy isn’t real either.
Do a little research and you will find that the judicial equivalent to a
farm team/minor league is the AG’s office.
It has been that way at least since the days of the late Bill
Brown. So if you want the dems to retain
the #1 farm team for future judges then go right ahead supporting Cordray.
2)
The AG sits on the Board of Deposits. Ask the banks if that is kind of a big deal.
3)
The AG appoints the members of the Board of the
Consumers’ Council. Ask the public
utility companies if that is kind of a big deal.
There are about six other things I could write down here,
but I believe I have made my point as to why DeWine might be better for the GOP
than Cordray.
In summary, I apologize for the length of this post. That was not my intent when I began. I guess I had a lot on my mind. We are truly at a crossroads as a party. The beautiful thing is that we have very
real, very obvious choices that we can choose to make that will be helpful or
hurtful to our collective chances on November 4, 2010. I hope a number of people in this state
(especially conservatives who care for Kasich, Taylor & Mandel) will think
long and hard before kicking the shit out of the likes of Husted and
DeWine.
You have the power.
Please choose to build with it and not use it to tear down &
destroy.